When medical bills exceed the at-fault driver’s policy limits, the insurer’s payment usually stops at the limit, and the client can still owe providers the unpaid balance. Firms commonly work on both sides of the gap: reducing what’s owed through bill negotiations and lien reductions, and finding more money through other liable parties, the client’s own underinsured motorist coverage, umbrella or excess policies, and, where the insurer mishandled a chance to settle, a bad faith claim. Which options are available depends on the facts and on state law.
The gap is common in serious injury cases. Many states set minimum auto liability limits of $25,000 or $30,000 per person, while a single surgery can cost more than that. This guide covers what happens to the unpaid bills, where additional recovery can come from, and how time-limited demands and bad faith fit in. For the basics of settling at the limit, see our guide to policy limits settlements.
Get a real-world look at how PI firms are putting AI to work across the full case lifecycle, including intake, medical management, litigation, and settlement strategy.
Watch NowIf medical bills exceed the policy limits, the at-fault insurer’s payment stops at the limit, and the client generally remains responsible to providers for the unpaid balance. Lienholders such as health plans, Medicare, Medicaid, and hospitals may also claim a share of the recovery. Firms commonly work on the bills and liens alongside the search for more coverage:
Sometimes. The at-fault driver’s insurer is generally only obligated up to its policy limit, but a judgment can exceed the limit, and the defendant is personally responsible for the excess. In practice, collecting an excess judgment from an individual is often difficult, which is why firms usually look first at other insurance.
The main exception that reaches the insurer itself is bad faith. In many states, an insurer that unreasonably fails to accept a reasonable settlement offer within the limits can become liable for the full judgment, including the amount above the policy. California recognized this in Crisci v. Security Insurance Co., 66 Cal. 2d 425 (1967), and Texas in the Stowers doctrine, from G.A. Stowers Furniture Co. v. American Indemnity Co., 15 S.W.2d 544 (Tex. Comm’n App. 1929). The standards differ by state.
| Source | How It Works | Common Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Other liable parties | An employer, vehicle owner, property owner, or manufacturer may share fault and carry its own coverage | Depends on liability facts |
| Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage | The client’s own policy pays when the at-fault coverage falls short | Rules on stacking, offsets, and consent to settle vary by state |
| Umbrella and excess policies | Extra liability coverage held by the defendant above the primary policy | Has to be found; not always disclosed up front |
| Defendant’s personal assets | An excess judgment can be enforced against the defendant | Often limited or protected from collection |
| Bad faith claim | The insurer may owe the excess if it unreasonably failed to settle within limits | State-specific standards and procedures |
Finding every layer of coverage early matters. Some states require insurers to disclose liability limits on request, such as Florida under § 627.4137 and Georgia under O.C.G.A. § 33-3-28. Our guide to policy limit investigations covers how firms trace coverage and liability.
One step firms often watch closely with UIM: many policies and state laws require notice to the UIM carrier, or its consent, before the client settles with the at-fault insurer. Settling without it can put the UIM claim at risk, so the order of settlements matters.
A time-limited demand offers to settle for the policy limits, or a stated amount within them, if the insurer accepts by a deadline. When a well-supported demand goes unanswered and a verdict later comes in above the limits, the insurer’s handling of that demand often becomes the center of a bad faith claim.
States regulate these demands differently. Georgia sets content and timing requirements for pre-suit offers in motor vehicle cases under O.C.G.A. § 9-11-67.1. Florida’s 2023 reforms (HB 837) changed the bad faith picture: under § 624.155, a bad faith action generally doesn’t lie if the insurer tenders the lesser of the limits or the amount demanded within 90 days of receiving notice with sufficient evidence, “mere negligence alone is insufficient to constitute bad faith,” and claimants have a duty to act in good faith in furnishing information.
Because a bad faith claim often turns on what the insurer knew and when, firms commonly make sure the demand includes complete medical records, bills, and a clear damages picture. A demand that documents damages well above the limits leaves little room to argue the claim was worth less. Our guide to writing a personal injury demand letter covers what a complete demand usually includes.
To tender the policy limits means the insurer offers to pay the full limit of its policy to resolve the claim. A tender often signals that the insurer sees its exposure as at or above the limit. In a case with several injured claimants, the limit may have to be divided among them, and in some states the insurer can interplead the funds with a court. Whether accepting a tender affects a UIM claim or other defendants depends on the release terms and state law.
On a case where damages clearly outrun the coverage, a demand that documents every dollar carries the most weight.
Express Demands, part of AI Drafts, drafts the demand from the case’s medical records and bills, so the full damages picture is in front of the adjuster. MedChrons builds a source-linked chronology of the treatment, and Medical Management flags missing records and bills while care is active.
When medical bills exceed policy limits, the recovery depends on finding every layer of coverage and on a demand that leaves no doubt about the case’s value. The coverage search, the order of settlements, and the handling of liens all shape what reaches the client.
Schedule a call to see how EvenUp builds demands that document the full value of a case.
Schedule a call today to see how EvenUp’s AI tools automate repetitive tasks, streamline custom drafting, and empower staff to focus on case strategy and client engagement.
Schedule Call