Guide

What Is a Motion to Compel? A Guide for Personal Injury Firms

Last Updated:

A motion to compel is a request asking the court to order another party, or a nonparty, to provide discovery it has failed to provide, such as unanswered interrogatories, missing documents or deposition answers. In a personal injury case, it’s the main tool a firm has when the defense lets deadlines pass, gives evasive answers or refuses to produce records. It sits inside the wider discovery process and usually comes after a failed attempt to resolve the dispute informally.

In federal court, FRCP 37 governs the motion, the required good-faith conference and the fees that follow. State courts add their own deadlines and filing requirements. EvenUp helps PI firms draft discovery responses from the case record, which keeps the firm’s own answers complete and harder to attack.

Five Points on Motions to Compel

  1. A motion to compel asks the court to order discovery that a party or nonparty has failed to provide.
  2. Under FRCP 37(a)(1), the motion must certify that the movant conferred, or tried to confer, in good faith before filing.
  3. FRCP 37(a)(4) treats an evasive or incomplete answer as a failure to answer.
  4. If the motion is granted, the court generally must order the losing side to pay the movant’s reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, with three exceptions.
  5. Ignoring an order compelling discovery can lead to sanctions under FRCP 37(b), up to dismissal or default judgment.

How Robles Jr Law Builds Cases with The Injury Specialists and EvenUp

Hear from Eric Hulett, COO at Robles Jr Law about how his firm uses EvenUp and The Injury Specialist to see where treatment has stalled or a specialist referral is missing.

Watch Now

What Is a Motion to Compel in a Personal Injury Case?

A motion to compel in a personal injury case asks the judge to order the other side to answer discovery it has ignored, answered poorly or refused. It turns a discovery obligation into a court order, and a court order carries sanctions if it’s disobeyed.

FRCP 37(a) lets a party move to compel when a party fails to answer an interrogatory under Rule 33, fails to produce documents or permit inspection under Rule 34, or when a deponent fails to answer a question at deposition. A motion directed at a party goes to the court where the case is pending. A motion directed at a nonparty goes to the court where the discovery is or will be taken.

Plaintiff firms file most often against defendants and their carriers. Defense counsel files against plaintiffs too, usually over medical history, prior injuries or authorizations. Both sides benefit from knowing the rule.

When Do PI Firms File a Motion to Compel?

PI firms typically file a motion to compel when discovery is overdue or deficient, the meet-and-confer effort has failed and the missing information matters to the case. Courts expect parties to try every informal fix first, and they notice when a motion is filed over something minor.

The five most common triggers in PI litigation are:

  1. Overdue responses. The defendant hasn’t served answers to interrogatories or responses to requests for production after the deadline and any agreed extension. Our guide to interrogatories covers the federal and state deadlines.
  2. Evasive or incomplete answers. The defendant answers with “unknown,” refers to unspecified documents or gives a partial answer to a multi-part question.
  3. Boilerplate objections. The response objects to every request on general grounds without stating specific reasons or saying whether documents are being withheld, as FRCP 34(b)(2) requires.
  4. Deposition failures. A witness refuses to answer questions, or a corporate defendant fails to designate a Rule 30(b)(6) witness.
  5. Examination and records disputes. The parties can’t agree on a defense medical examination under FRCP 35, or a nonparty provider or employer won’t comply with a subpoena. Under FRCP 45(d)(2)(B)(i), the serving party may move to compel production in the court where compliance is required.

Records disputes often start before suit. A firm that already tracks every outstanding request, as our guide on how to retrieve medical records for lawyers describes, can show the court exactly what was asked for and when.

What Is the Meet-and-Confer Requirement Under FRCP 37(a)(1)?

The meet-and-confer requirement means the moving party must try to resolve the dispute with the other side before filing. FRCP 37(a)(1) requires the motion to include a certification that the movant “has in good faith conferred or attempted to confer” with the party failing to provide discovery, in an effort to get it without court action.

A credible meet-and-confer record has five parts:

  1. A deficiency letter. It lists each request, the response given and why it falls short.
  2. A specific ask. It states what a complete response looks like and proposes a date.
  3. A real conversation. Many courts expect a phone call or meeting, so firms often check the local rules and the judge’s standing order.
  4. A written follow-up. It confirms what was agreed and what remains in dispute.
  5. A certification. The motion itself describes the dates, the method and the result.

Skipping this step costs more than a delay. Under FRCP 37(a)(5)(A), the court must not award expenses to a movant who filed before trying in good faith to get the discovery without court action. Our discovery objections cheat sheet covers how to respond to a deficiency letter when the firm is on the receiving end.

Get Your Sample Interrogatories and Responses for Personal Injury Cases

See what a strong interrogatory response looks like with this downloadable sample: a full set of a defendant’s interrogatories with a plaintiff’s strategic answers.

Download Now
Downloadable interrogatories examples against plaintiffs

How Do Courts Treat Evasive or Incomplete Answers?

Courts treat an evasive or incomplete answer as no answer at all. FRCP 37(a)(4) says that “an evasive or incomplete disclosure, answer, or response must be treated as a failure to disclose, answer, or respond.” That rule closes the gap a party might try to use by serving something on time that says nothing.

Response ProblemExampleHow It Is Treated
No responseDeadline passes with nothing servedFailure to respond; untimely objections may be waived under FRCP 33(b)(4)
Evasive answer“Plaintiff’s injuries speak for themselves”Failure to answer under FRCP 37(a)(4)
Incomplete answerLists two of five witnesses known to the partyFailure to answer under FRCP 37(a)(4)
General objection“Overbroad and unduly burdensome” with no reasonsObjection grounds must be stated with specificity under FRCP 33(b)(4) and 34(b)(2)(B)
Silent withholdingObjection with no statement on withheld documentsDoesn’t meet FRCP 34(b)(2)(C)

A party that fails entirely to serve answers to interrogatories also faces a direct sanctions motion under FRCP 37(d)(1)(A)(ii), without a prior order. Requests for admission work differently. An unanswered request is deemed admitted under FRCP 36, so the remedy is often to rely on the admission, as our guide to requests for admissions in a personal injury case explains.

Who Pays Fees and Expenses on a Motion to Compel?

The losing side usually pays. FRCP 37(a)(5) makes fee shifting the default, which is why a well-documented motion often prompts complete responses before the hearing.

OutcomeWhat the Court Does Under FRCP 37(a)(5)
Motion granted, or discovery provided after filingMust require the party or deponent whose conduct made the motion necessary, the advising attorney, or both, to pay the movant’s reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, after a chance to be heard
Motion deniedMay issue a protective order and must require the movant, its attorney, or both, to pay the opposing party’s reasonable expenses, unless the motion was substantially justified or other circumstances make an award unjust
Granted in part and denied in partMay issue a protective order and may apportion the reasonable expenses

A granted motion doesn’t trigger fees in three situations:

  1. The movant filed before attempting in good faith to get the discovery without court action.
  2. The opposing party’s nondisclosure, response or objection was substantially justified.
  3. Other circumstances make an award of expenses unjust.

Fee shifting cuts both ways. A firm that files over a weak dispute can end up paying the defense’s costs.

What Happens if the Other Side Ignores an Order to Compel?

If a party disobeys an order compelling discovery, the court can impose sanctions under FRCP 37(b)(2)(A). The sanctions grow more severe as the disobedience continues, and they can decide the case.

The court may issue seven kinds of orders:

  1. Directing that designated facts be taken as established for the action
  2. Barring the party from supporting or opposing certain claims or defenses, or from introducing certain evidence
  3. Striking pleadings in whole or in part
  4. Staying further proceedings until the order is obeyed
  5. Dismissing the action in whole or in part
  6. Rendering a default judgment against the disobedient party
  7. Treating the failure as contempt of court, except for an order to submit to a physical or mental examination

The court must also order the disobedient party, its attorney or both to pay the reasonable expenses caused by the failure, unless the failure was substantially justified or an award would be unjust. For a plaintiff firm, an established-facts or evidence-preclusion order against the defendant can reshape trial preparation. The same risk applies to the firm’s own clients, which is why complete and timely responses matter.

How Do You Defend Against a Motion to Compel?

A party defends against a motion to compel by showing that its responses were complete, its objections were specific and justified, or the request itself was improper. The strongest defense is a response set that never needed a motion.

When the defense moves to compel a client’s responses, firms often work through five steps:

  1. Reviewing the meet-and-confer record. If the movant skipped or rushed the conference, the opposition can say so with dates.
  2. Supplementing where the motion has a point. Serving a complete supplemental response can narrow the dispute, though under FRCP 37(a)(5)(A) the court can still award expenses if the discovery arrives after filing.
  3. Defending each objection on its own terms. The opposition explains why a request is overbroad, disproportional under FRCP 26(b)(1) or privileged, with specifics tied to the case.
  4. Seeking a protective order where needed. A request for unlimited medical history or social media access may justify an order under FRCP 26(c), which has its own conference certification.
  5. Showing substantial justification. A reasonable dispute over scope can defeat a fee award even if the court orders more discovery.

Consistency helps on both sides of a motion. Answers that match the medical chronology and the records are hard to call evasive. For drafting the responses themselves, see our guide on whether AI agents can draft discovery responses.

Draft Discovery and Motions From the Same Case Record

Most motions to compel come from responses that were late, thin or built on boilerplate. The fix is the same on both sides of the dispute. It means drafting from the full case record, stating objections specifically and documenting every conference.

AI Drafts drafts responses to interrogatories, requests for admission and requests for production, applies the firm’s objection logic and tone, and ties every fact to a line-level citation. Companion retrieves key facts with line-level citations across the raw records and creates documents from the case context and firm standards, which supports deficiency letters and motion drafts. The attorney decides what to file and signs it.

Schedule a call to see how EvenUp helps your team draft discovery responses and litigation documents from the case record.

Scale Your Firm Without Scaling Payroll

Schedule a call today to see how EvenUp’s AI tools automate repetitive tasks, streamline custom drafting, and empower staff to focus on case strategy and client engagement.

Schedule Call
Schedule call with EvenUp

Explore More